News DeskOpinion

The Business of Music Is Running Out of Musicians

The music industry is generating record revenues. Streaming platforms are reaching global audiences. Concerts are selling out. And yet, for many of the people actually making the music, earning a living from it has never felt more difficult.

The Pit StandardOpinion
The Business of Music Is Running Out of Musicians
Photo by Marianne Brits

Being heard has never been easier. Making enough money to keep going is another matter entirely.

Musicians are expected to write, record, release, promote and perform, often financing much of it themselves. They are competing for attention in an overcrowded market, navigating streaming platforms that rarely provide a sustainable income and taking financial risks just to get their music in front of an audience.

The industry measures success in streams, ticket sales and revenue. For musicians, success is increasingly measured by whether they can afford to keep going.

There has never been a time when releasing music was quite so accessible. An artist can record a track, distribute it across streaming platforms and reach listeners around the world without a record label or major investment.

But being able to release music and being able to make a living from it are two very different things.

The work doesn't stop once a track is uploaded. Recording, mixing, mastering, artwork, equipment, rehearsal space, promotion and distribution all come at a cost. Then there is the constant demand to remain visible online, produce content, communicate with listeners and find ways to stand out in an increasingly crowded market.

For independent musicians, much of this work is unpaid. Many are effectively running small businesses alongside their creative practice, taking responsibility for their own marketing, administration, finances and career development, often while holding down another job.

The financial reality is not limited to those trying to break through. Musicians with years of experience, established audiences and substantial catalogues can still struggle to make their work pay.

The problem isn't a lack of music being made. It's whether the people making it can afford to continue.

The streaming paradox

Streaming has transformed the music business, but the financial relationship between platforms and the people creating the music remains deeply contested.

In 2025, the UK recorded music market generated £1.57 billion in revenue, its highest nominal figure to date. Streaming accounted for £1.07 billion, or 67.7% of that total. These are significant figures for an industry that has spent years rebuilding its recorded music revenues. But they describe the market's income, not what individual musicians take home.

The distinction matters.

Streaming services generally distribute royalties to rights holders rather than paying every performer directly at a fixed rate per play. What reaches an individual musician depends on who owns the recording, their contractual arrangements, distribution agreements, publishing rights and any other parties entitled to a share.

For an independent artist releasing their own recordings, the arrangements may be relatively straightforward. For someone signed to a label, working with a publisher or sharing rights with collaborators, the picture can be considerably more complicated.

A study published by the Oxford Internet Institute and the University of Groningen in April 2026, based on a survey of 1,198 musicians across five countries, found that 83% were dissatisfied with the royalties they received from streaming services. At the same time, 81% said streaming was important to their careers, yet fewer than half felt their situation had improved since streaming became dominant.

Researchers described this as the 'streaming paradox': musicians depend on platforms for visibility and audience reach, but many don't believe the financial return reflects that importance. The research covered Brazil, Chile, the Netherlands, Nigeria and South Korea, rather than the UK, but its findings expose a tension that runs throughout the modern music business.

The problem is not simply that individual streams pay relatively little. It is that musicians are increasingly dependent on a system they have limited power to negotiate with. More plays may mean greater visibility, but they don't necessarily translate into meaningful income.

And visibility has become another job in itself. The same Oxford research found that 69% of musicians were spending more time promoting their music online than they had a few years earlier. The expectation is to keep releasing, posting, engaging and building an audience, often without knowing whether the additional work will produce any financial return.

A growing audience is valuable. But it doesn't pay for a mixing engineer, a rehearsal room or the next month's rent.

The cost of getting on the road

Live performance has become an increasingly important part of the financial picture. For many musicians, touring and performing offer opportunities to earn money, sell merchandise, develop an audience and build relationships that streaming alone cannot provide.

But the economics can be brutal.

Transport, accommodation, food, equipment, insurance, crew and rehearsal costs all need to be covered before an artist can calculate whether a show or tour is worthwhile. For musicians travelling with other performers, those costs multiply. A run of dates that looks promising on paper can quickly become unprofitable once everything is accounted for.

Ditto Music's Independent Music Report 2026 surveyed 5,039 independent artists across 112 countries. It found that 82% could not currently afford the expenses associated with touring. Among artists who perform live, 66% said touring costs had increased. Streaming was the largest single source of income among respondents, with live performance and touring the second largest. Yet the costs of accessing that second income stream are proving prohibitive for many.

These figures come from Ditto's own artist community and represent independent artists using its distribution services, rather than the entire global music industry. Even with that qualification, the findings point to a significant problem.

The pressure isn't limited to emerging artists. In an interview with The Pit Standard, Peter Yanowitz of New York trio Princess Goes spoke about the practical and financial difficulties of taking their latest album, 3, on the road.

Despite the experience of its members and an existing catalogue, the band has no confirmed touring plans. Coordinating the schedules of three busy musicians is difficult, and Yanowitz says the cost of touring has risen considerably. He hopes the album will reach new listeners and eventually bring the band back in front of audiences, but wants to wait until the timing is right.

It's a useful reminder that the economics of touring don't disappear once a band has established itself. Even musicians with years of experience and an existing audience have to consider whether the numbers make sense.

The wider live music business also deserves scrutiny. A UK parliamentary inquiry into competition in the live music industry raised serious concerns about market concentration, exclusivity arrangements and the influence of major operators across promotion, venues, festivals and ticketing.

Evidence submitted to the Committee by the Association of Independent Festivals showed that, of the 23.1 million primary tickets examined for 2025, Live Nation directly controlled 58%, rising to 66% when tickets controlled by affiliated companies were included. The Committee also examined concerns that restrictive arrangements and bundled touring deals could limit opportunities for independent venues and promoters.

These figures do not, on their own, establish anti-competitive conduct. But they raise important questions about who holds power in the live music market, and how that power affects artists and smaller businesses.

The disappearing infrastructure

The pressure on artists is inseparable from the financial position of the venues that support them.

Music Venue Trust's 2025 annual report recorded 30 permanent grassroots venue closures during the year. More than half (53%) of the UK's grassroots music venues made no profit, while average profit margins across the sector stood at just 2.5%. The organisation also reported that 175 UK towns and cities no longer received regular touring shows by professional artists.

These are not simply small businesses struggling to balance their books. Grassroots venues are part of the infrastructure that makes a music career possible. They provide stages, employment, rehearsal and development opportunities, and places for audiences to discover artists outside the major touring circuit.

When they disappear, the consequences travel further up the industry. Fewer independent venues mean fewer places for artists to play, fewer opportunities for independent promoters and fewer routes for audiences to discover music.

There is also a question of how the wider live industry contributes to keeping that infrastructure alive. The voluntary £1 contribution on arena and stadium tickets was introduced to direct money towards grassroots music. The Government's Music Plan, published in July 2026, confirmed that the LIVE Trust had already distributed £1.5 million to initiatives supporting artist touring, grassroots venue development and smaller festivals.

The Government is backing wider adoption of the contribution, with the money intended to be reinvested in the grassroots music sector. More than six million pledges had been made since the scheme's introduction in January 2025, according to LIVE.

If the biggest events benefit from the artists, audiences and venues that make up the wider music ecosystem, contributing to its survival should not be optional in the long term.

What needs to change?

The response cannot simply be to tell musicians to work harder, release more music or become better at marketing themselves. Nor can it rely on occasional grants and emergency funding for venues already close to shutting their doors.

The financial model needs to be examined at every level.

Streaming requires greater transparency and fairer remuneration. Musicians should be able to understand how revenue is calculated, how it moves through the rights chain and what deductions are made before it reaches them. Contracts and royalty arrangements need to be clearer, particularly for performers and songwriters who may not own the recordings they create.

The same scrutiny needs to extend to live music. Support acts should not be expected to absorb substantial travel and accommodation costs in exchange for exposure. Promoters and headline artists need to consider fairer guarantees and more transparent expense arrangements, while touring grants should be easier for independent musicians to access.

The voluntary contribution on arena and stadium tickets is a welcome starting point, but the survival of grassroots music cannot depend on goodwill alone. If voluntary participation cannot deliver consistent support, a mandatory levy should be considered, with funding directed towards independent venues, festivals, promoters and the wider touring network. There must also be transparency about how that money is collected and distributed.

Financial support needs to reach artists themselves, too. Ireland offers an example worth examining through its Basic Income for the Arts programme. The 2026–2029 scheme is designed to provide 2,000 selected professional artists based in the Republic of Ireland with €325 a week for three years. It follows an earlier pilot, whose evaluation reported positive effects on artistic practice, wellbeing and financial security.

It is not a universal payment, and places are limited, but the principle is important.

Creative work requires time. Artists cannot devote themselves to developing their practice if they are constantly having to prioritise other employment simply to meet basic living costs.

The UK should be prepared to explore a similar approach. Rather than relying solely on short-term project grants, direct financial support could give professional musicians some stability and the freedom to create, record, rehearse and develop their careers. Ireland’s pilot offers evidence worth considering, although its results should not be treated as a guarantee that an identical scheme would have the same impact in the UK.

The economic case for investment is substantial. UK Music’s This Is Music 2025 report found that the industry contributed £8 billion in gross value added to the UK economy in 2024, generated £4.8 billion in export revenue and supported 220,000 full-time equivalent jobs. Sustaining that contribution means investing in the people and infrastructure that make the industry possible.

Support must also extend beyond individual artists. Affordable rehearsal spaces, independent recording facilities and grassroots venues all need long-term investment and protection. They are not peripheral to the music industry; they are part of what allows it to function.

There is a responsibility here for labels, publishers, promoters, platforms and major live operators. The commercial success of the music business depends on a continuing supply of new work and new talent. That cannot be taken for granted while the people creating that work are left to shoulder so much of the cost.

Audiences also have a part to play. Buying tickets, supporting smaller venues and purchasing merchandise directly from artists all make a difference. Streaming remains a valuable way to discover and listen to music, but it should not be mistaken for meaningful financial support on its own.

The price of keeping music alive

The music industry is very good at talking about growth. It celebrates record revenues, streaming milestones, sold-out tours and global audiences. But those successes tell only part of the story.

Behind every release is time, labour and investment. Behind every tour is a financial calculation. Behind every independent venue is a business trying to survive on margins that leave very little room for error.

The UK Musicians' Census, conducted by Help Musicians and the Musicians' Union, found that average annual income from music work was £20,700, with 43% of musicians earning less than £14,000 a year from music. More than half (53%) needed income from outside the industry to sustain their careers. Based on nearly 6,000 UK musicians, the 2023 Census remains an important benchmark for understanding the financial pressures facing working musicians.

These figures describe income from music work, rather than musicians' total personal income. But they are a stark reminder that years of experience and professional commitment do not necessarily translate into financial security.

This is not an argument that every musician should be guaranteed commercial success, or that making music should be free of financial risk. It is an argument that the people creating the value should have a fairer opportunity to share in it.

The industry cannot keep asking musicians to create the music, fund its development, promote it, take it on the road and absorb the losses, while measuring success through the revenues generated elsewhere.

We have made music easier to access than at any point in history. The next challenge is making the business of creating it sustainable.

If music is such a successful industry, it is time to ask why so many of the people who make it are still struggling to earn a living from it.