News DeskNews

Nick Cave calls AI-generated music “our final, most soul-destroying humiliation”

Nick Cave has delivered a fresh criticism of AI-generated music, describing the technology as an affront to human creativity and warning that it threatens to make artists themselves unnecessary.

The Pit StandardNews
Nick Cave calls AI-generated music “our final, most soul-destroying humiliation”
Photo by Ian Allen

Writing in the latest edition of his fan Q&A website, The Red Hand Files, the Bad Seeds frontman responded to questions about artificial intelligence, including whether he considered himself a “doomer or boomer” when it came to the technology.

Cave admitted he remained uncertain about AI’s wider implications.

“Artificial Intelligence, Catherine, may save the world, annihilate it, or do something in between. I don’t know,” he wrote.

His position was considerably less ambiguous when discussing AI-generated music, however. Singling out music-generation platform Suno, Cave questioned how software could produce meaningful artistic expression without the human experiences that inform songwriting.

“They mock creation itself by rendering humanity unnecessary, taking the fruits of human striving and reducing them to mere products. It is, perhaps, our final, most soul-destroying humiliation,” he wrote.

He went on to describe Suno as “the Great Cancellator”, arguing that its ability to generate songs within seconds undermines the work and personal experience involved in creating music.

Cave also questioned the value of music produced without the emotional experiences traditionally associated with songwriting, including love, grief, joy and heartbreak.

Describing the technology’s output as “an imitation of the soul”, he called it “an affront to any songwriter who has lived and struggled in this world and earned the right to create a song”.

His response also addressed the relationship between an artist and their work. Cave argued that the artist has traditionally been inseparable from the creative process, but warned that AI threatens to remove the human creator from the equation altogether.

“Not just that, the artist – that flawed, messy, broken, woeful, joyful problem – can be removed from the equation altogether, like so much dross,” he wrote.

Cave has previously been outspoken about the implications of artificial intelligence for music. In 2023, he criticised lyrics generated by ChatGPT in his writing style, describing them as “a grotesque mockery of what it is to be human”.

His position on AI as an artistic tool has, however, shown some nuance. Last year, filmmaker Andrew Dominik used AI to animate archival photographs of Elvis Presley for a video accompanying the 40th anniversary of the Bad Seeds’ 1986 track Tupelo.

Cave praised the resulting film as a profound interpretation of the song, acknowledging that it had shifted his perspective on the creative possibilities of the technology.

His latest comments focus more specifically on AI-generated music and the prospect of automated platforms producing songs without human songwriting at their centre.

He also suggested that the prospect might appeal to those who have sought to exclude controversial artists from the cultural conversation.

“For those eager to rid the world of problematic artists – for these censorious forces remain persistent – it is surely cause for celebration, as these platforms promise to rid the world of artists altogether.”